Skip to content

Sunday, November 22, 2026

USDA pushes soring rule for Tennessee Walking Horse shows to Dec. 31, 2027

Tennessee Walking Horse owners, trainers and show organizers won't have to meet the federal government's amended horse inspection rules before Dec. 31, 2027, now that the U.S. Department of Agriculture has postponed them once more.

A rule in the Federal Register from USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, known as APHIS, extends the delay. It moves the start date for the 2024 Horse Protection final rule a year later, from Dec. 31, 2026.

In a report, the House Appropriations Committee said the rule's cost-benefit analysis "severely underestimates the impact the rule will have on the 20,000 jobs supported by the Tennessee Walking Horse industry."

It told APHIS to withdraw the rule and work with the industry on objective, science-based ways to end soring, the abuse the Horse Protection Act is meant to stop.

APHIS has already proposed doing that. On Friday, Nov. 13, it put forward a plan to strip out the sections a court had vacated, withdraw what's left of the 2024 rule and update the regulations. Public comment on that plan runs 30 days, ending Monday, Dec. 14.

There isn't enough time to review those comments before Dec. 31, 2026, the agency said, so any final rule would arrive after the 2024 rule's start date.

Letting a partly vacated rule kick in meanwhile "would almost certainly have disruptive consequences," APHIS wrote, warning that shifting rules could prove costly for the industry it oversees.

The delay took effect immediately. APHIS skipped public comment on the postponement itself, saying it had good cause and that regulatory clarity was needed.

A federal court has already struck down much of the 2024 rule. In January 2025, the court in Texas' Northern District threw out its ban on action devices, pads and substances, along with the provision on skin conditions and the review procedures.

One piece survived. It upheld the rule's plan to swap the industry's Designated Qualified Persons program for Horse Protection Inspectors.

That same court sided with plaintiffs in a second case on Friday, Aug. 28. It found that the No-Showback Rule and Scar Rule go beyond USDA's authority and that the disqualification process lacks due process.

USDA published the rule on May 8, 2024, with a start date of Feb. 1, 2025, for all but one section, which began June 7, 2024.

Freda Dean of Tennessee fought the rule back when it was only a proposal. Her club's show, where most of the horses are padded performance horses, would end under it, she wrote in a 2023 comment.

"The scholarships and community support dollars that our club provides to deserving local equestrians, over $115,000 in the last twenty years that I have kept the records, will be gone, eliminated," she wrote.

Owners, trainers and show organizers who want a say on withdrawing the rule have until Dec. 14 to comment on the November proposal.